Test Cut, Test Mark. A purposely made cut into the edge of a numismatic item by unthinking people to ascertain the item's base composition. Usually this occurs to a plated piece, but even solid metal items – particularly precious metals, gold and silver – are susceptible to such unfortunate practice. People who make test cuts are not professionals, but amateurs who think a test cut is considered a way to make a quick assay of the item's fineness. Unfortunately this practice is a mutilation of the item and it lowers both numismatic condition and value. Instead, to ascertain the base metal a specific gravity test or other nondestructive tests should be conducted. Only if these are inconclusive, should a very light file cut be made in the most unobtrusive part of the rim where a magnifying glass would reveal the color of the base metal (but even file cuts are discouraged by some).

In America the mutilating test cut (where metal is removed) is also called a knife cut, in both Britain and the continent, a chisel cut. Cuts in silver objects, usually near the hallmarks were once called assay groove in previous centuries. An unintentional, but sometimes similar defect on the edge – as from dropping a piece – is called edge nick; the two should not be confused.

The purpose of the test cut is to identify the color of the underlying metal. This

may not be obvious at first inspection, for example, copper may appear pink instead of red. For other color identities see bleeding.

Test marked coins. Breen relates the history of four dates of Carson City silver dollars, 1870-73, which often exhibit test marks. After claims were made that these CC dollars were lightweight and low fineness, the Philadelphia Mint ordered samples sent to them for assay. This proved to be true, resulting in the dismissal of the Carson City Mint Superintendent, H.F. Rice. Publicity of this caused widespread testing of these dollars by banks and individuals, with many returned for melting. A few remaining specimens still exhibit test marks where this testing once occurred. The gold coins struck at Carson City of the same period were also suspect but Breen did not report observing test marks on any of these.

Never perform a test cut to the edge of any coin or

medal. This drastically lowers the value and such an

item is considered damaged. If you are seeking the

identity of the base metal or under composition it is

best to perform a nondestructive specific gravity test.

If this is inconclusive, then have a professional perform

a file cut for a microscopic examination of the base

metal. Do not perform test cuts yourself!

References:

NC7 {1988} Breen [dollars 5485, 5489, 5493, 5495].